Home food main dishes A Simple Thanksgiving Dinner
A Simple Thanksgiving Dinner

 asimplethanksgivingdinner.pdf   thanks1

I'm sure I’ve mentioned before that Thanksgiving skipped a generation in our family.  “What does that mean?” I can hear you asking.  Well, my mother’s mother was the creator of Thanksgiving when I was growing up.  Even then, I think it was my favorite holiday.  My entire family, (which was fewer than 12), all gathered at my Grandmother’s for the wonderful day.

However, the year my Grandmother passed away, it was in October, and frankly, my mother and I were lost on Thanksgiving without her.  We worked together, making her recipes as best we could.  But as we all know, Grandmother’s don’t write anything down…they just made food! Since that first Thanksgiving, I’ve taken over and my Mom brings the mashed potatoes and all is well.

In fact, this year, I was thinking about how nice and easy Thanksgiving has become and that I still make her simple recipes.  So, to those just starting out or to those interested in a simple Thanksgiving, I’d like to relay the process and the recipes of that meal we all shared and how Thanksgiving doesn’t have to be full of exotic dishes made out of strange ingredients.  Simple is best and I promise you’ll enjoy it just as much!  FYI, this isn’t Martha’s Thanksgiving, if you know what I mean!

A Simple Menu

  • Turkey
  • Stuffing
  • Gravy
  • Mashed Potatoes or Sweet Potatoes
  • Vegetable
  • Cranberry Sauce
  • Dinner rolls
  • Pumpkin Pie with Whipped Cream

Tip:
Not all of the food on the menu needs to be homemade.  I purchase the cranberry sauce from my local grocery store along with dinner rolls and a bakery made pumpkin pie.  The whipped cream of choice, Redi-Whip because you can shoot it straight into your mouth!!  Ahh simple pleasures!

The Thanksgiving Turkey & Stuffing

thanks2

Butterball it has been, only because that is what my Grandmother used, at least since Butterball was available.  This year I will stray from the Butterball to try an organic turkey and I’ll let you know how that all works out for me.

So, start with a turkey.  Make sure to follow the instructions for thawing.  Then, on the morning of Thanksgiving, unwrap it and don’t forget that there are surprises inside for you! 

 

thanks3

 

Giblets and necks and livers and yuk!  I’ve been making the turkey for 30 years now and I still don’t like the giblets bag.

 

 

 

 

thanks4

 

In the process of washing the turkey inside and out, I look for feathers that didn’t get removed and pluck them.  I also cut off the tail that is often stuffed inside. 

 

 

 

When the turkey is clean and patted dry, I place it in a large foil pan to await the stuffing.  This is a good time to preheat the oven to 325 degrees.

Stuffing Ingredients:

  • ½ cup diced onion
  • 4 Tbsp. margarine
  • 1 ½ cups diced celery
  • 1 cup chicken bullion
  • 30 slices of bread
  • 1 tsp. salt
  • 3 eggs scrambled in milk
  • Parsley
  • Poultry seasoning
  • 1 lb. mild Italian sausage (optional)
  • 1 ½ cups chopped walnuts

Stuffing Instructions:

1.  The whole stuffing process actually begins the night before Thanksgiving for our family.  The girls all convene in the kitchen and start chopping stuff up.  My daughter likes to cube the bread and then she spreads it in a pan to dry out a bit overnight.  My Mom and I chop up the celery, onion, and walnuts and put them in baggies in the refrigerator so cooking in the morning goes faster.

thanks6

 

2.  Fry the celery and onion in the margarine until tender but not brown.
I have to say that once the aroma of the celery and onion cooking starts to permeate the house, I know that Thanksgiving is really here.  Usually the parade is on while I make this and I’m basically in heaven! 

 

 

thanks7

 

3.  Pour the celery and onion mixture over the cubed bread (which I put in another large foil pan to match the one the turkey is sitting in) and mix in well.

 

 

 


thanks8

 

4.  Add the cup of hot chicken bullion and 1 teaspoon of salt and stir.  Next add the three eggs scrambled in milk and blend in well.

 

 

 

 

thanks9

 

5.  Add the parsley and poultry seasoning.  Again, no measurements from Grandma so I just eyeball it.  I put in more parsley for good color and flavor and just sprinkle around the poultry seasoning. 

 

 

 

thanks10

 

6.  Chopped walnuts are next.  Stir in well.  For my family, I then put some of the stuffing in a casserole and bake it separately from the turkey.  For other members of the family, I continue with the other half of the stuffing.

 

 

 

thanks11

 

OPTIONAL:  My Grandmother always put mild Italian sausage into her stuffing as you see me doing here.  Cut open the casing and break it into tiny pieces and spread throughout the stuffing mixture.  All my life I picked out the sausage, so now I make the stuffing the two different ways!

 

 


If you are baking your stuffing separately, place it in a casserole and bake covered for 30 to 45 minutes or until heated through.  If you are stuffing the turkey, (which I do, with the sausage stuffing) follow along.

 

thanks12

 

I stuff the body cavity first, keeping in mind not to pack it tight.  In fact it is supposed to be pretty loosely stuffed. 

 

 

 

 

thanks13

 

Use the leftover stuffing for the neck cavity which can be pretty big itself. 

 

 

 

 

thanks14 


To hold the stuffing in the neck cavity, I fold the neck flap over the opening, closing the stuffing inside and then bend the wings towards the back to hold the neck flap in place.

 

 


thanks15

Notice I have the legs tucked into the strap of skin by the tail.  This helps hold the stuffing in place here as well. 

See I have placed the turkey, breast side up, on a rack in the shallow foil baking pan.  You may notice I have doubled the pans for strength.  Brush the bird lightly with oil so it doesn’t dry out.


 

thanks16

 

Insert a meat thermometer into the center of the inside thigh muscle making sure the thermometer does not touch bone.

 

 

 

A turkey is baked based on its weight and whether it is stuffed or not.  Most turkeys come with instructions that will guide you as far as timing goes.  A basic 12-16 lb. stuffed turkey takes approximately 4 to 4 1/2 hours to cook.  To prevent overbrowning, cover the turkey loosely with foil once the skin reaches a golden brown, (about 2/3 through cooking). Remember though; keep your eye on that meat thermometer.  Mine reads 190 degrees for poultry though I’ve heard 180 degrees as well.  The stuffing should be between 160 and 165 degrees to be done.

When the turkey comes out, let it stand with the foil in place for 15 to 20 minutes before carving.

thanks17

 

Make sure your carver has all the right equipment.  We use an electric carving knife and the job goes quite easily. 

Here are some tips for carving;

1.  Hold one of the legs out from the body and cut through the skin and meat and the joint between the leg and the body and remove.  Separate the thigh and drumstick by cutting through the joint.  Repeat on other side.

2.  To remove the breast meat, make a cut just above the wing horizontally through the breast meat toward the rib.  Then, starting just to the side of the breast bone, cut along the ribs to remove an entire breast section.  Move to a cutting board to cut the breast meat into slices.

While the carving is happening, my Mom starts the gravy.

 

Pan Gravy Ingredients:

  • Pan drippings from the roasted turkey
  • Cornstarch
  • Water
  • Salt
  • Pepper

1.  Pour about two cups worth of pan drippings into a saucepan.  Skim off the fat and start heating the pan drippings on medium.

2.  In a large measuring cup add about 1 cup of warm water and about two tablespoons of cornstarch and stir together until mixed.  Slowly add small amounts of this mixture to the pan drippings, stirring constantly to mix thoroughly.  The pan drippings will turn opaque and slowly begin to bubble.

3.  When the gravy is of the color and consistency you prefer, boil and additional minute, add salt and pepper to taste and pour into your favorite gravy boat!

thanks18

So, if I take a look back at my simple Thanksgiving menu, I owe you a mashed potato recipe, a sweet potato recipe and a vegetable.  Remember, the rest of the items were purchased ready to bake or ready to eat!!  Just like this ready to warm up “turkey” dinner roll! Isn’t this the cutest batch of dinner rolls you’ve ever seen?  The best part of this whole thing is that my husband does the Thanksgiving shopping and HE saw this and picked it out!  I was thrilled and the kids thought it was the greatest.  One negative….no one wants to be the first to break off a leg!

Anyway, on to the veggies.  Since my Mother makes the mashed potatoes, I have the recipe but not the pictures to go along with it.  However, I’m sure you can make these without my beautiful photography to help you along.

Holiday Mashed Potatoes  recipe card icon

  • About 15 medium potatoes, peeled, cooked and hot
  • 1  8 oz. pkg. cream cheese – room temperature
  • ¼ cup butter or margarine
  • ½ cup sour cream
  • ½ cup milk
  • 2 eggs, lightly beaten
  • ¼ cup finely chopped onion
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • Dash pepper

1.  In a large bowl, mash hot potatoes with mixer or by hand. 

2.  When all lumps are gone, add cream cheese in small pieces and then the butter.  Beat well until the cream cheese and butter are both melted and completely mixed in. Add in the sour cream.

3.  Add eggs and onions to the MILK and then add this to the potato mixture along with salt and pepper.  Beat well until light and fluffy.

4.  Place in a greased 9 inch round casserole and refrigerate several hours or overnight if not using immediately.

5.  Bake in preheated 350 degree oven for 45 minutes or until lightly browned on top.  Makes 8-12 servings.  (Only if you eat like a bird…we always double the recipe for 8 of us so there are leftovers!!)
 

If you are interested in the yummiest sweet potatoes you’ve ever eaten, check out the Twice Baked Sweet Potatoes recipe in the vegetable section.
And as for vegetables for our Simple Thanksgiving Dinner, my family prefers simply corn or steamed green beans.  With all the other flavors going on, who needs anything else to overpower the gentle flavors of the turkey, stuffing and potatoes?

thanks19

And besides, isn’t it the people who are sitting at your table that matter the most?  It’s not about the buns burned on the bottom, or the cold mashed potatoes, the turkey that just won’t get done or the fact that everyone is stuffed from eating all the appetizers.  As long as we are with family and friends, we are the luckiest people around.  But, as with most families, you better get the pumpkin pie right or you’re never going to hear the end of it!  Hahaha!

Have a wonderful, relaxing and Happy Thanksgiving!

Shari

 
© 2009.  mattandshari.com, all rights reserved.
 

Comments (24)Add Comment
Marie
...
written by Marie, October 29, 2009
THANKSGIVING IS DEFINATELY THE BEST HOLIDAY!
All about FAMILY.

I feel like having some stuffing right now. Maybe I can doctor up some Stove-top for a snack? Nah...

But,

I want those turkey rolls!
Cathy48315
...
written by Cathy48315, October 30, 2009

Shari,

I sure wish I had this article about 25 years ago! I learned the hard way about the fun surprises hidden inside a turkey....AFTER it was roasted!(Ewwww!) Now I've got it down pat (like all us Moms after 20 years). One thing I like to do is use latex gloves while cleaning it. Sure makes hand sanitizing much easier when done!

I want to mention that your Grandmother's stuffing is very similar to what I grew up on. It's not common to find stuffing recipes without Sage! Even the bags of dry bread cubes contain Sage, so we have to cube our own bread for stuffing.

Thanks for the great article.... you've made me HUNGRY!!
~Cathy
Shari
...
written by Shari, October 30, 2009
Hi Cathy!

You know, I almost didn't add the stuffing recipe because it seemed so plain. However, it is what I grew up on and I LOVE it! We've always cubed our own bread and I can't imagine using a bag of cubed bread. I'm probably really missing out on something!!

I guess my Grandmother, living on a farm, didn't know about the exotic spices and just cooked perhaps like HER mother cooked. It's really wonderful to think about isn't it? What woman started that recipe? How far back in my history did that begin? Oh, if I had only known to ask all these questions while my Grandmother was alive.

I am very sentimental, and I think that is why Thanksgiving means so much to me. I start thinking about my grandparents and our family and get all teary eyed. (I do keep it to myself or my family laughs at me!!!)

Have a wonderful Thanksgiving Cathy, and I'll be thinking about you as my daughter and I cube the bread on Thanksgiving Eve!!
Cathy 48315
...
written by Cathy 48315, October 30, 2009
Oh Shari, Thank you! That warms my heart!

Family is everything to me. I think about my Grandparents and how they had a coal stove to heat the whole house and the winters visiting them we had to run outside and up the hill to use the outhouse! Not many people MY AGE have memories like that, but to me they are WONDERFUL. So why would I change my Grandmother's recipe that is just simple, but delicious food? Especially for a special occasion such as Thanksgiving. Anything different wouldn't help bring back the wonderful memories of our childhood and it wouldn't help form the warm, wonderful memories for my kids. I'm all for new recipes and exciting dishes, but not for Thanksgiving!!

Wishing you a warm and wonderful Thanksgiving too, and if you think about it.... YOU aren't the one missing out on something by cubing your own bread!
Marie
...
written by Marie, October 30, 2009

I'm betting that the Poultry Seasoning does have sage in it.
I have never seen a brand that does not list it in the ingredients.
Shari
...
written by Shari, November 02, 2009
Marie, you are right, sage is only second to thyme. there is also marjoram, rosemary, black pepper and nutmeg. Wow! I guess I use more spices in my stuffing thatn any other recipe I make!! Hahaha!

Cathy48315
...
written by Cathy48315, November 04, 2009
Hi Marie -
I know, you are so right about the poultry seasoning! It's really hard to find stuffing mixes and dried bread cubes without sage and rosemary. Guess that's why we've always had to make our own from scratch. Funny thing - there was ONE brand of stuffing mix that offered a mushroom & onion flavor without sage that was close in taste to our homemade, and just this year they discontinued it! That's okay though. I really like cutting up all my own ingredients anyway. Makes it all taste better! Hope you have a nice Thanksgiving too.
~Cathy
Marie
...
written by Marie, November 05, 2009
Hi, Cathy --
We also make our stuffing from scratch. We like to buy a little variety of rolls/bread to cube. I like having a lot of egg rolls in the mix. I dry them out in the oven on warm.

Shari, I would like to see a food section with some international recipes on this website. I am sure many people have traditional holiday recipes that come from their heritage. I got a nice Ukrainian horseradish egg spread recipe from Cathy via the old message board. A traditional family recipe section would be nice. My family has certain holiday recipes that come from 'the old country', too.
Happy holidays!
Marie
Shari
...
written by Shari, November 05, 2009
Hi Marie,

Great idea. Maybe we can call out a request for great old family recipes with an international flair and folks can send in the recipe with some photos and I can format it to fit the site. It would be a very nice addition to our food section. Thanks for the idea! BTW, two things, I finally found the no sew napkins and washed them. Just a small seam pull up at the corners where the fabric is thick. A touch up with the iron and another tiny piece of iron on hem tape and they were fine. Also, I added the paragraph about getting rid of your old clothing and Matt will add that ASAP. Again, thank you for the suggestions!
Marie
...
written by Marie, November 05, 2009
Matt already added the clothing paragraph in, 'cause I read it earlier today.
I will look at what recipes I may have to send you.

I would love to have some more traditional ethnic recipes for different holidays. Or, once there is enough of a collection, that could serve as a good base for an international food party. Have guest each bring in a cultural food creation.








Bonnie G
...
written by Bonnie G, November 06, 2009
I use a similar recipe for my mashe dpotatoes, but I don't put eggs in them. I will have to try that once.

Loved the turkey dinner roll. Can you send your husband out to shop for me smilies/wink.gif
Seriously, what bakery did he find that at, maybe they have one in Ohio.

Bonnie
Trina
...
written by Trina, November 06, 2009
Shari, What could be any better than a simple Thanksgiving Dinner with family
and some close friendssmilies/smiley.gif
Shari
...
written by Shari, November 10, 2009
Hi Bonnie!

I'm not sure what the eggs do to the recipe, but the potatoes are out of this world. Especially if you aren't counting calories!! You know, we do our shopping at Publix down the street and I think they just made some interesting stuff in their bakery for the holidays. If you could find a nice bread recipe, you might be able to make one following what they did. Oh, and send your list, I'll get him on it!! He loves to shop because he thinks I take too long and then buy too many extra things! (It's all a part of my plan, of course!)
Trina
...
written by Trina, November 12, 2009
Hi Shari,
I would like to try your mashed potatoes for our Thanksgiving. Is their any way I can print out the recipe without printing the whole article? Its a new recipe that I would like to keep in my new recipe folder.

Thanks
Shari
...
written by Shari, November 13, 2009
Trina,

Matt and I are working on a pdf that you could click on to just get the recipe. Stay tuned!
Shari
...
written by Shari, November 14, 2009
Trina,

Matt created the cutest recipe card and we've been working on getting all the ingredients and instructions on one card. This week I'll bet we have it perfected so give us a couple more days. I think we'll put a new button at the top of the recipe if there is a recipe card available. Stay tuned!
Cathy 48315
...
written by Cathy 48315, November 14, 2009

Shari,

The tabs for recipe cards would be great. You guys are really getting good at this technical stuff!
~Cathy
P.S. Just love the picture of your husband armed and ready for the meal!
matt
...
written by matt, November 16, 2009
Hi everyone, we have added a recipe card for those of you that would like to print out the directions and ingredients only (but please read the whole article) look for the little recipe card icon, I will be placing those in all of our recipes as fast as I can build them.
Shari
...
written by Shari, November 16, 2009
The little recipe card icon is right at the recipe in the article and it looks fantastic! Great job Matt. Did you work into the wee hours of Friday night to get these done???
Trina
...
written by Trina, November 16, 2009
Shari, Matt

You guys did a great job and you got it done so fast. You must have worked on it all weekend.smilies/cheesy.gif Again great job and no more writer's cramps.

Have a great Thanksgiving from my family to yours.
Dani
...
written by Dani, November 25, 2009
The items in your Simple Menu is exactly the same that my Grandmother cooked when I was growing up! I now cook the same meal for my family. Several times I tried to "update" them with crazy ingredients, but honestly, they did not taste nearly as good as the tried and true versions. I enjoy cooking the family faves although since I recently went vegan, the turkey will share the spotlight with a veggie loaf this year. Nothing beats a simple Thanksgiving meal with family.
Shari
...
written by Shari, November 25, 2009
Dani,

You and I really need to talk! My husband has recently gone vegan and the rest of us are vegetarian. We are having turkey because my parents aren't ready for the big change. I am trying to learn how to eat all over again and it's hard to get out of the "meat and potatoes" mentality that we've grown up with. What is in a veggie loaf?
I_Fortuna
...
written by I_Fortuna, October 27, 2011
I love the turkey dinner roll. My hubby likes sausage and black olives in his dressing. I opt to make mine the way my mom did, onion, celery, sage, chicken broth and Mrs. Cubbison's. For the Vegans:
I once had vegetarian "turkey" at the Inn of the Seventh Ray in the canyon in L.A. Wow was it great. They make it with seitan but what else I am not sure. They serve all vegetarian food and organic wine, it is great! There is also a veggie restaurant in Alhambra, Happy Family, and you cannot tell that it is vegetarian food the way it is prepared.
Shari
...
written by Shari, October 27, 2011
I've had vegan turkey before,frozen from the store and it wasn't too tasty. I actually haven't ventured into seitan yet. I"m still trying to perfect tofu and tempeh! We'll cheat and have turkey for Thanksgiving but I make sure to get an organic one.

Write comment
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 

Swedish Meat Balls

swedish

Swedish meatballs are always a party favorite.  Who doesn’t like eating their food with a toothpick!

 

 

read more

Seasonal Appetizer Bowls

appetizerbowls-1

Anyone can bring out the china or glass appetizer or snack bowls, so why not create something unique that your guests will keep talking about after the party is over!

 

read more

 

 

dvd and book special 

 


Join Matt and Shari
*receive our newsletters
*members only articles

login or register

  Bookmark and Share

tupperware spring

our store banner

facebook

Egg McMama

egg-mcmama

You won't want to miss this homemade version of the famous fast food breakfast treat! 

read more

Irish Soda Bread

bread7

A

traditional treat around St. Patrick's Day.  This one is especially tasty due to the golden raisins!

read more

Making Green Beer

greenbeer

Looking for a great beverage to celebrate this month?  Make your own green beer and let the blarney roll!

read more

Corned Beef

cornbeefsandwiches

A great little sandwich with a spicy punch! 

 

read more